Promote your business or product on 700level.com. For
more information about advertising with us CLICK HERE!

Agree that on pure likability and "being memorable" I go with Randall over Donnie. I also think youth plays a role... The 10-11 year old ENY remembers Cunningham hurdling the Packers into the end zone, the play vs. Buffalo, etc... I was oblivious to his off-the field exploits, which I can't say with regards to McNabb.

while i enjoyed the others you mentioned, i cant rightfully place any in the top 20 over past 2 decades.

No Mike Quick, no Barnett, no Keith Jackson, no William Thomas, no Vincent?

FB, i considered most of those guys but again i did it off top of head to spur convo.

list your top 10 and hopefully others will do likewise.
i already conceded that i shoulda maybe included akers over someone.



and again, only the past 20 yrs everyone...

I like how people look at me strange when I tell them I'd prefer Randall over McNabb.

"What has Cunningham won?"
"Same as McNabb. And I'll remind you Randall played in an era where the SB champ was usually coming out of the NFC East or San Fran"

Randall > McPukeyRib

If i were to just look at numbers id agree w/ you- and longevity is whatd put him over 12

but i cannot get over what a douchey mommas boy 5 was is, let alone the McMartyr crap.

I will not get over anytime soon how McNabb helped to ruin a combo in him and TO that could've been dominant for years. Yes, TO is nuts and yes, he did his part as well, but TO's acting like, well, TO

Didn't Jerome die before the '92 season? And Randall can't be on there if we're only talking >'92 either.

Who else you gonna choose from that time period? Bobby Hoying? Rodney Peete? Ty Detmer?

It's like choosing between pails of dishwater

Ty Detmer was money

Dino- 12 was on the team in 92

He was done after bein benched in favor or ROTney Peete in 94 I believe.

After the birth of his child, remember that fiasco?

Didnt take his play book?

Had to play V Dallas.

Looked a mess???

Yes but he sucked by '92.

Seth - you must really hate McNabb if you're going to put a dead guy and a washed up QB ahead of him. I know he was annoying and all, but damn.

Its not about 'numbers' per se.


Jerome was far more of an eagle great than McRib ever was.

Cmon man.

He died in the summer of '92!

FIne then expand the period of years to 25 yrs then!

Or slide in Akers if you're bound to my 1st set of perams.

your call.

Brown only played 5 years and made two pro-bowls

There's also that little matter of killing a 14 year old by driving like a dickhead.

Doesn't make the list, hell I'd put William Thomas ahead of him

Agree with Neag.


Another guy who doesn't deserve to be on that list is Trotter

Aside from his untimely death, my lasting memory of Jerome Brown is the way Tecmo Super Bowl turned a 305-lb. DT into a 3-4 MLB with blinding speed.

FB who are your top 10 'Eagle Greats" (Not statistical leaders per se) of the past 20, 25 yrs?

Is it 20, 25, 30, 43 years?


You keep changing the criteria

WOW this site has changed since the days of someone doing something dumb and then gettin jumped on...


I mean dam, haven't been here since last year sometime, but felt a disturbance and a violation against DAWKINS... I gotta call Seth out for his clever but poorly placed THREAD JACK!!!

Come on now this thread should be for Dawk only, he was the best Safety the Eagles ever had, not only could he cover like a CB but he hit like a freight train. Defensive Co's had to game plan with him in mind... "He was also the heart and leader of the Jim Johnson Defense for a decade" ( was from Diddy I think on DNL but agree 100%)

and just my 2 cents he gets into the HoF...


So now move the who's the top 10 to it's own thread, OR maybe we should all meet up in the concourse and give each other nicknames...lol

Hey guys.. if this thread is to honor #20, we shouldn't go on about McRib, ok?

Dawkins is awesome. I wish he stayed here for a few more years. Hoping they put him in the HOF (pull a few strings, will you Jeff?) and retire his number.

A Mexican midget and big purple dinosaur are now the thread police?

And I'll remind you Randall played in an era where the SB champ was usually coming out of the NFC East or San Fran"

One of those two things happened literally every year during the last 10 years of Randall's tenure here.

The only consistent competition in the NFC from 2000-2009 was the 2000-2003 Rams and the 2006-2009 Saints.

Roachie...I mean this from the bottom of my heart...
I LOVE YOU!!

excellently done video by The Eagles that preceeded Dawk's speech today.


I couldnt embed it so just hit the link.


linc

1 2